Controversy over the election of Milett Figueroa as a judge on "Cantando 2024"

Social media and the press have erupted in a wave of criticism and comments following the recent election of Milett Figueroa as a judge on the new singing reality show "Cantando 2024." The popularity of the Peruvian model and actress has been a subject of debate due to her background in the music industry, and her romantic relationship with the well-known Argentine presenter Marcelo Tinelli has intensified the backlash against her. In the face of this torrent of criticism, Tinelli has not remained silent. In a passionate defense of his partner, the Argentine host emphasized Milett's talent, noting that she has studied singing at a conservatory in Lima. "Milett sings very well," Tinelli stated, highlighting that her presence on the judging panel was not merely a whim due to their personal relationship, but a decision based on her musical ability. The context of the controversy is further complicated by the opinions of some media experts. Journalist Agus Rey has been one of the most critical, suggesting that Milett is not qualified to judge singing performances, arguing that her lack of experience could lead to uncomfortable situations for both her and the contestants. "Milett judging singing is like judging a game of chess," Rey expressed, pointing out the limitations the model may face in her new role. However, Tinelli's defense has resonated with various sectors, who argue that talent is not always measured by a long career in music. The role of a judge on a singing show can be diverse, and Milett could bring a different perspective. "She's there because she has something to offer," Tinelli insisted, reaffirming his confidence in Figueroa's ability to perform her role effectively. Additionally, the situation has been exacerbated by the recent leak of a video showing Milett at the Latina studios, fueling rumors of her return to the show "El Gran Chef Famosos." This context broadens the focus on her figure, further elevating her media profile and simultaneously generating expectations about her participation in "Cantando 2024." As the premiere of "Cantando 2024" approaches, the audience remains divided. On one hand, there are those who support Milett, highlighting her bravery in entering a field where criticism can be relentless. On the other hand, there are skeptics who believe that her media fame is not enough to justify her role as a judge on a program of this magnitude. This debate reflects a broader struggle in the entertainment industry regarding the value of talent versus notoriety. It is also important to mention that the role of influencers and celebrities in music has changed in recent years. Many figures from the entertainment industry have ventured into singing, blurring the traditional lines that once separated musicians from other professions. While the criticism of Milett may be based on her lack of experience, it can also be seen as part of a broader trend where the audience is willing to accept different types of talent. The question that remains is whether Milett's talent will be enough to silence her detractors on "Cantando 2024." The pressure will be on her shoulders not only to demonstrate that she can judge with discernment but also to show that her path in the music industry is legitimate. In this sense, the series of challenges Milett faces transcends the personal realm and becomes a matter of professional credibility. As the promotion of the show progresses, the public's eyes will be on her, not only because of her relationship with Tinelli but also due to how she will handle the demands of being a judge. Her partner's defense may be a boost, but at the end of the day, it will be her own performances and decisions that will determine her future in the world of singing. In this scenario, time will tell whether Milett Figueroa can establish herself as an artist in her own right or if the criticism will continue to shape her path.